So yeah, I know we said we were going to put up our full rankings before the Tony Awards, but then I had a thought: Why would anyone want to listen to the podcast if we just posted the rankings? So, we waited. Gave you some time to listen to the podcast. And I think it’s fair to say now that if you’ve gone this long without listening to it, you probably aren’t going to. So anyway, here are the rankings, in their entirety. First mine, which I have already released in full on the podcast, and second Bryan’s, for the very first time anywhere.

Someone please yell at him for having “What’d I Miss?” way, way too low.

My Exhaustive and Inarguable Rankings

  1. Alexander Hamilton
  2. My Shot
  3. Burn
  4. Satisfied
  5. Non-Stop
  6. Farmer Refuted
  7. Say No To This
  8. The Room Where It Happens
  9. Wait For It
  10. Helpless
  11. Guns and Ships
  12. It’s Quiet Uptown
  13. Take A Break
  14. The World Was Wide Enough
  15. Your Obedient Servant
  16. You’ll Be Back
  17. What Comes Next?
  18. The Election of 1800
  19. Cabinet Battle #1
  20. Cabinet Battle #2
  21. The Schuyler Sisters
  22. One Last Time
  23. Dear Theodosia
  24. Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story
  25. Aaron Burr, Sir
  26. What’d I Miss
  27. Ten Duel Commandments
  28. The Story of Tonight – Reprise
  29. History Has Its Eyes On You
  30. Right Hand Man
  31. The Story of Tonight
  32. Yorktown (The World Turned Upside Down)
  33. That Would Be Enough
  34. Best of Wives and Best of Women
  35. Washington On Your Side
  36. I Know Him
  37. Hurricane
  38. Stay Alive
  39. Meet Me Inside
  40. The Adams Administration
  41. Blow Us All Away
  42. Stay Alive – Reprise
  43. We Know
  44. A Winter’s Ball
  45. The Reynolds Pamphlet
  46. Schuyler Defeated

And Bryan’s…

  1. Wait For It
  2. My Shot
  3. The World Was Wide Enough
  4. Yorktown
  5. Non-Stop
  6. Right Hand Man
  7. Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story
  8. Satisfied
  9. Say No To This
  10. The Reynolds Pamphlet
  11. One Last Time
  12. The Room Where it Happens
  13. Burn
  14. Dear Theodosia
  15. Helpless
  16. Schuyler Sisters
  17. You’ll Be Back
  18. Guns and Ships
  19. Your Obedient Servant
  20. Alexander Hamilton
  21. History Has Its Eyes on You
  22. Cabinet Battle #2
  23. Cabinet Battle #1
  24. Election of 1800
  25. Story of Tonight (Reprise)
  26. That Would Be Enough
  27. Story of Tonight
  28. Ten Duel Commandments
  29. Meet Me Inside
  30. Take A Break
  31. We Know
  32. It’s Quiet Uptown
  33. Aaron Burr, Sir
  34. Farmer Refuted
  35. What Comes Next?
  36. A Winter’s Ball
  37. I Know Him
  38. The Adams Administration
  39. Washington On Your Side
  40. Hurricane
  41. Stay Alive
  42. Stay Alive (Reprise)
  43. What’d I Miss
  44. Schuyler Defeated
  45. Blow Us All Away
  46. Best of Wives and Best of Women

Let us know where we screwed up, and share your rankings in the comments section below!